America's finest companies, 2010
Curated by Brian Kim, CPA — every pick gets a plain-English summary and the key takeaways.
Brian Kim, CPA · 2.89M YouTube Subscribers →What this book actually teaches
- 01The core screen — ten or more consecutive years of earnings or dividend growth — filters for companies with durable competitive advantages or conservative management, not just recent momentum.
- 02The 2008-2009 financial crisis served as a quality filter for the AFC list: companies that maintained their records through the recession had meaningfully stronger business models than the pre-crisis cohort.
- 03Staton's philosophy aligns with dividend growth investing: buy consistency, reinvest dividends, hold long-term, and avoid the transaction costs and behavioral errors that come with frequent trading.
- 04The consecutive-years screen does not account for valuation — a company can pass the filter and still be an overpriced investment, so follow-up valuation work is necessary.
- 05The specific 2010 company list is outdated and should be used as a framework illustration rather than a current buy list.
What's in this book
Bill Staton's America's Finest Companies is an annual investment guide built around a simple, rules-based screen: companies that have increased their revenues or earnings per share, or both, for at least ten consecutive years. Staton, a money manager and financial columnist, has published updated editions of the list since the late 1980s, and the 2010 edition covers the universe that survived the 2008-2009 financial crisis with their records intact. The core argument is that dividend and earnings consistency is a more reliable predictor of long-term investment quality than analyst ratings, recent stock price performance, or media coverage.
The book is structured as both an investment philosophy and a reference directory. The philosophy section explains Staton's case for buying and holding from the AFC list rather than attempting to time the market or chase momentum: companies with decade-plus records of earnings or dividend growth have demonstrated durable competitive advantages, conservative financial management, or both, and a portfolio of them — particularly bought during market downturns — has historically compounded at rates that beat most actively managed funds. The directory section lists the qualifying companies with basic financial data, designed to give readers a starting screen for their own research rather than a buy list.
The 2010 edition's timing is relevant: many companies that had been on the list were eliminated by the financial crisis, and the survivors — companies that maintained or grew earnings through one of the worst recessions since the Depression — had meaningfully stronger business models than the pre-crisis list would have suggested. Staton uses this as evidence for the quality-filtering power of the consecutive-years criterion.
The investment framework is philosophically aligned with dividend growth investing as practiced by more widely cited investors like John Neff and Geraldine Weiss: buy quality at a reasonable price, reinvest dividends, hold for years, and don't overthink it. For retail investors who want a low-complexity approach, the logic is sound.
For long-term retail investors who want a simple, low-turnover approach to equity investing built around earnings and dividend consistency rather than valuation models or market timing.
Weaknesses
the 2010 edition is a time capsule — the specific company list is outdated and several names from it will have since been acquired, delisted, or had their streaks broken. The screening criteria (ten consecutive years of earnings or dividend growth) are straightforward but don't account for the quality of those earnings, leverage levels, or valuation. A company can grow earnings for ten years and still be an overpriced investment. The book also lacks rigorous backtesting of the strategy's risk-adjusted returns relative to a simple S&P 500 index fund, which is the most relevant benchmark for retail investors considering whether the active screen adds value.
Verdict
a useful introduction to dividend and earnings consistency as an investment filter for retail investors willing to do their own follow-up research, but the 2010 edition's specific company list should be treated as illustrative rather than actionable. The current edition, if one exists, or an independently maintained screen is more useful than this edition for practitioners.
Read next
For anyone who wants to invest seriously without becoming a day-trader — beginners willing to read carefully, and exp…
Buy on Amazon →
Early- and mid-career W-2 employees who want a single, executable wealth-building plan without becoming amateur portf…
Buy on Amazon →
For individual long-term investors who can hold concentrated positions for five to twenty years and want a framework…
Buy on Amazon →
For experienced investors who are comfortable with DCF mechanics and want a more disciplined, market-price-anchored f…
Buy on Amazon →About Bill Staton
Read more from Bill Staton and explore the full bibliography on ClearValue Books.
View Bill Staton's page →Get an email if our take on America's finest companies, 2010 changes.
We re-review our picks. We'll email you if America's finest companies, 2010's ranking or review changes — no checking back.
Ready to read America's finest companies, 2010?
Buy the edition we recommend on Amazon.
Buy on Amazon →